The Nonsense of Disney’s Valuation
Hugh Johnston has been doing this for a long time. The current CFO of The Walt Disney Company has held that title at two major businesses.
Before Disney, Johnston spent 34 years at PepsiCo and served as CFO for 13 of those years. He’s one of the most respected financial wizards in corporate America.

So, when Johnston publicly vents about something, it must be bad.
He understands the nonsense of Disney’s current valuation. Let’s talk about what he knows.
Understanding High Finance

Atlanta Falcons
I won’t bore you with high concepts about economics. Let’s use a sports analogy instead. Do you ever think, “Team X is terrible, and Team Y is gonna kill them?”
I do that whenever the Atlanta Falcons line up for a game…and I’m often wrong. As a diehard Falcons fan, I should always expect an 8-9 season, but I’m an optimist by nature.

Photo: Atlanta Falcons
Anyway, the point is that I’d always bet on the Falcons, which is precisely why I don’t gamble.
Wall Street possesses a gambling equivalent to this tactic known as a short sale.

Photo: History.com
When an investor thinks that Corporation X is wildly overvalued, they short-sell it. Basically, they “borrow” stock shares and sell them immediately.
Then, they wait for the stock to drop and then buy it at the lower value.
In gambling terms, they’re betting that the team currently leading the division won’t win.

Photo:NYpost.com
When that happens, they earn a financial reward as well as personal vindication.
By short-selling the right stock, an investor benefits greatly, and I can prove it.

AP Photo/Richard Drew, File
Let’s say that you short-sell a $100 stock, and it eventually drops to $80.You’ve earned $20 in profit on your investment for each share that you short-sell.
Short selling is actually one of the most dangerous things an investor can attempt. Charles Schwab’s website describes the process but ends with a section entitled “Proceed Carefully.”
Does Anyone Bet Against Disney?

Photo: Playbuzz.com
Despite the glaring risk, especially on long-term shorts, many investors try them.
When they succeed, they can be epic. In fact, the film The Big Short covers this very topic.

Michael Burry bet against the entire housing market and thereby earned hundreds of millions of dollars. It’s the same as saying, “The Los Angeles Rams won’t win the Super Bowl.”
They’re currently the Super Bowl favorite by a large amount, despite what happened in Australia, so it’s a risky bet. Using another movie example,

Photo: adage.com
tells the story of the GameStop meme stock.

Someone punished short sellers by convincing a large number of people to buy GameStop stock.
Since it was currently valued at less than $20, the buyers earned a fortune.

Photo: Wikimedia
Those holding short sales lost billions of dollars in the process.
Long story short, when you bet against a corporation, you better be right.

Photo Credit: AP Photo/Richard Drew, File
Whenever Wall Street frequently short-sells a stock, everyone knows it’s overvalued.
Keeping that in mind, here’s a list of the most frequently shorted stocks.

Image: The Wall Street Journal
You don’t know many of these companies because it’s dangerous to short anything with name recognition.
I’ve linked to something that updates live, which means you will see a different list.

Photo: restorethemagic.com
However, the only recognizable entity when I write this is Jack in the Box Inc. This restaurant chain has struggled so much lately that you’d think Nelson Peltz is running it.
A more interesting conversation involves the stocks that investors are NOT short-selling. SeekingAlpha posted this article last week. It compiles the “safest” stocks.

Photo: Wikimedia
While nothing is ever certain in the world of high finance, this list remains compelling.
It’s a tell-tale sign of what Wall Street actually thinks of corporations. And there’s one name on the list that should get your attention. It’s Disney.
The Nonsense of Disney’s Valuation

(Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)
Compared to other mid- to mega-cap stocks, Disney’s one of the safest bets.
Its short interest is just 1.10 percent, which places the company in rare air.

Photo: measureupgroup.com
Currently, the primary list of stocks in this range involves the military-industrial complex.
With military conflicts raging in Iran and Ukraine, those businesses are doing well. Conversely, Disney’s primary business model relies heavily on disposable income.
So, you’d think that investors may be worried about the economy impacting the parks.

Disney
Well, as I’ve previously discussed, Wall Street has repeatedly said that.
However, the data indicates that few believe Disney is overvalued.

Photographer: Michael Nagle/Bloomberg via Getty Images
On the contrary, investors have voted with their wallets on the point.
If Disney did appear overpriced, the stock would be heavily short-squeezed.

Photo: Bank rate
That’s not what we’re witnessing right now. In fact, it’s the exact opposite. Fewer people are short-selling Disney than BlackRock! That’s a staggering stat.
Given everything that has happened with Disney lately, you may wonder why. Wall Street famously punishes Disney for any perceived shortcoming.

Hugh Johnston (Photo Credit: CNBC)
The explanation comes down to something Johnston recently discussed on CNBC.
During the appearance, Johnston joked about Disney’s valuation.

Photo: PepsiCo
Investors examine a variety of factors, including the price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio.
Again, I won’t bore you with the specifics, but let’s just say Disney is being treated unfairly. As Johnston notes, Disney possesses a powerhouse P/E of 16.8.
In sports terms, Disney is the equivalent of a soon-to-be free agent.

Photo: PepsiCo
The player has overachieved based on their initial salary, and now they’re ready to get paid.
Savvy investors view Disney in the same light, which explains the lack of shorts. As Neil Patel at The Motley Fool notes, Disney’s stock “represents a 33% discount to the overall S&P 500 index.”
Is Disney’s Stock Undervalued?
Here’s the tricky part of the conversation. The answer is that nobody knows.
Past performance does not indicate future results. That’s a Wall Street maxim.

Image: The Healthy Mouse
Over the past decade, Disney’s stock has gone absolutely nowhere.
Lately, the stock has been undervalued, as demonstrated by the metrics I’ve discussed.

(Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)
Still, there’s no guarantee that the stock will move at all, even though it’s undervalued. For whatever reason, investors simply don’t like Disney stock these days.
Could that change under new CEO Josh D’Amaro? So far, the answer is yes. Investors at least seem willing to give him a chance.

Photo:Dreamstime
Importantly, with few short sells in the marketplace, Disney stock can more easily increase.
There’s no short-related pressure weighing it down, which does matter in the marketplace.

Photo Credit: Disney
In addition, almost every major investment firm – it’s seriously more than 90 percent – lists Disney stock as overweight. That’s another clear sign that the stock should improve at some point.
Of course, people have been saying that since Bob Iger returned in November 2022. The stock still hasn’t escaped its current range of mid-80s lows and 110s highs.

Photo: Josh D’Amaro in Instagram
As a numbers guru from way back win, I’m fascinated by this paradox.
Most believe that Disney stock should do something, yet few investors put their money where their mouth is.

Photo: skillastics.com
In a nutshell, that’s the nonsense of Disney valuation.
Note: I hold a small position in Disney, but it’s so trivial that it barely even matters.

Thanks for visiting MickeyBlog.com! Want to go to Disney? For a FREE quote on your next Disney vacation, please fill out the form below. One of the agents from MickeyTravels, an EarMarked By Disney – Authorized Travel Agency – Diamond Level, will be in touch soon!
Feature Photo: Disney


